Shingle, metal, tile or flat? Choosing a roofing material
A plain comparison to take into your conversation with a roofer.
Rather book online? Compare roofers on Thumbtack, our partnerIndependent local roofing companies · Repairs, new roofs and re-roofs · No obligation
Rather not call?
Get roofing quotes online in 30 seconds
Tap your roof type and add your ZIP to see roofers that serve your area.
- 3 quick taps, no long forms
- Local roofing companies near you
- No obligation to hire anyone
| Material | Typical life | Good fit | Upkeep |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asphalt shingle | 20–30 yrs | Almost anywhere | Light |
| Metal | 40+ yrs | Snow, wind, wildfire areas | Light |
| Clay / concrete tile | 50+ yrs (underlayment less) | Hot, sunny climates | Medium |
| Slate | 75+ yrs | Older homes, cold climates | Specialist |
| Cedar shake | 20–40 yrs | Drier, airy settings | Higher |
| Flat (TPO, EPDM, mod-bit) | 15–30 yrs | Near-flat sections, additions | Medium |
Your roof's pitch, local building rules and how long you'll stay in the home all matter. A roofer who sees the house can narrow it down quickly.
